Wednesday, December 3, 2008

What My Parents Taught Me About Video Games


[My Mom and Dad]

Part of the reason I ended up doing game journalism is, I think, because of my Dad. He was a tech journo when I was a kid, which meant we had everything in the house worth playing for a good chunk of my lucky, lucky youth, and it means he's still pretty up on things today.

Whenever I wonder about the Wii's new audience, I just picture my early-fifties Mom holding the Wii Remote and declaring, ecstatically, a revelation to my father: "Michael! I'm really doing it!" That was a pretty promising day, I thought, because up until then the only involvement Mom had with video game consoles was to passive-aggressively vaccuum over the controller cords while I was trying to play.

So when my parents drove me back to New York City after I spent Thanksgiving in Massachusetts with them, I decided to show my parents some more new stuff, educate them about the miracle of new technology and the richness of present-day player experiences. I think I ended up learning more than they did, though.

My Dad Is Sony's Ideal Audience

This time, my Dad wanted to know about the PlayStation 3. Jack Tretton would thrill if he could hear Dad tell Mom all about how the PS3 is worth its price for the Blu-ray player alone -- and plus, said Dad, the PS3 has Tourist Trophy. Vehicle games are a major selling point to my motorcycle hobbyist father.

To gamers, the much-touted PS3 Blu-ray drive justifies the console's decidedly uncompetitive price just about as much as Nintendo still makes "hardcore" games -- which is to say it's a hilarious idea. First, we all saw how angling the PS3 as anything other than a video game console came to bite Sony -- and how fast they backpedaled as publishers showed signs of skittishness. Now, everyone who'd like to see the platform succeed knows that it needs to be cheaper, and hangs the blame on the Blu-ray decision.

When Kaz Hirai introduced the PS3 by enthusing about Blu-ray, and became upset that no one was interested in Ridge Racer, we all wondered who Hirai thought he was talking to. Guess it was my Dad -- turns out that Blu-ray drive is a significant factor to someone after all.

Dad wanted to check out a game with cars, though, and I had the excellent Midnight Club: Los Angeles for the Xbox 360 on hand. Knowing him, I had to hurry to skip the introductory cut scenes in order to get to the gameplay. After all, this was one of my rare opportunities to share my hobby (and my career) with my parents hands-on -- they tend to glaze over during my articles -- and I knew that if Dad had to sit through dialogue he'd lose interest.

MCLA held Dad's attention for about five minutes. He liked accelerating, but complained that he hates playing an analog stick with his left hand (he's right handed). He tried flipping the controller upside down to reverse the situation, but, of course, that reverses the controls, too. After about 30 seconds of playing the 360 controller in his lap with his hands crossed, he had enough.

If You've Got A Gun, It's A Shooter

I decided to see what my parents thought of Fallout 3, expecting them to be floored by just how far games had come since I was a brat mashing buttons on their living room floor. I loaded up a save that I had just outside Vault 101, where the nuclear wasteland was breathtaking and ready to explore.

"What is this?" Mom asks. "Where are you supposed to be?"

"It's post-apocalyptic Washington," I tell her. "It's really, really cool."

"It doesn't look like Washington," says Mom. "It just looks like... I don't know what." She is not impressed. "How is this Washington?" she keeps wanting to know.

"So this is a first-person shooter, huh?" Dad says.

"No," I insist. "It's more like an RPG, where --"

"Well then, what's that?" Dad points at the screen, where my big pistol is filling up the corner of the first-person view. "Why do you have a gun if it's not a shooter? It sure looks like a shooter to me." He does this partly because he knows he's oversimplifying and thinks it's funny that I'm getting irritated (and now you know where my contrarian nature comes from).

I have to admit, though, he really does have a point.

I start explaining to my parents all about action RPGs, and how FO3 isn't really an FPS, and I'm trying to talk about "actions affect the gameworld" and "death of the American dream" and "environmental storytelling," and suddenly it sounds ridiculous to me.

For just a minute, I see the game as my parents see it -- a guy with a gun trundling across a wasteland. The end.

What Are You?

Instead, I decide to start thinking of the things Mom would enjoy about a game console. She loves casual games, and she pretends to be a technophobe, but if she actually has a chance to acclimate to social media-type things, she tends to get hooked. So I explain to her about small downloadables, indie games, online casual titles and leaderboards, and the only thing I have on hand as an example is PixelJunk Eden. It's no Zuma or anything, but I feel pretty convinced that my parents will find it more relatable than FO3.

It's kind of an art game, I explain, I talk a lot about music and color and flowers growing, and then I put it on.

"This isn't colorful," says Mom, wondering if she's missed something. "I just see blue."

"Well, the colors change when you get these things... you have to pop all these flowers --"

"What flowers?"

It's a little more understandable to them after I play for a minute or two, pollinate a few seeds and keep climbing, but Mom needs to know, "What are you? Is that, like, a scorpion?"

The question of what are you has always seemed highly irrelevant to me when playing PixelJunk Eden -- but, honestly, my best friend, who's a much more acclimated gamer, frequently gets hung up on the same issue.

"Nah," says Mom, after some assessment. "I don't think I would like this."

"Mom wouldn't like this," Dad agrees.

Still, my parents might get a PS3. But the real takeaway of their test drive, for me, was their perspective on this little capsule of my everyday living room experience.

And, you know, my parents aren't totally clueless.

"Your writing isn't as good as you think it is, you know," said my Dad to me earlier on the road trip. "Your articles are too long. You need to at least break things up with subheads, or add some pictures, or something. If nobody gets to the bottom of your article, you're wasting time."

My Dad definitely knows a thing or two about this stuff.

48 comments:

DavidBoring said...

i get to the bottom of your articles...

SVGL said...

Thank you, David! Take THAT, Dad! :)

Kevin said...

Trying to write something else insightful, but all I can say is what david up there already said... I get to the bottom of your articles, too!

Mister Raroo said...

I really liked reading this article! :-)

Alan said...

wow, there are comments down here?

Nihil said...

You are Michel Foucault's daughter?

Bruno Dion said...

Pretty interesting to see how your job, and your hobby, is seen by people that are far from the gaming industry.

And yeah, parents saying their child could do their job better. The world never changes.

Fred Zeleny said...

I have a similar situation with my parents. They're very tech savvy for people in their early 50s, but they don't have time for larger games, and are slightly intimidated by the more complex controllers for consoles. They're perfect candidates for smaller, more casual games, and they've logged a truly unbelievable amount of time on Fantastic Contraption.

However, they have very good eyes for elements of writing, narrative presentation, and deeper artistic and societal themes. So if I can present bits of a game to them without them playing, we have long discussions about the deeper meanings or implications of a game - as we'd analyze any other piece of media.

But it's always interesting to see them play a game, because I learn a lot, too. They're not opposed to games, but they haven't learned any of the fundamental assumptions that lifetime gamers take for granted.

The best example of this is my step-father, who enjoys casual driving, who saw me playing Driver long ago, and was interested by the option of driving a car around a realistic city. So he sat down for a spin, and had a great time taking a leisurely trip until he accidentally ran a red light, and the police started following him.

Being a responsible driver, he pulled to the side of the road. But since apparently no designer had assumed the player would do that, the police simply proceeded to ram his parked car, over and over again, until it blew up.

Apparently, no one had ever considered the player might try following the law. Crazy, huh?

(Oh, and obviously I write long, as well. But I don't think it means your writing is bad.)

lastgunslinger said...

I think we're more impressed with advances in video games because we've never had things like realistic graphics or artistic expression for its own sake before the mid 90s. Our parents, however, have had those things in film and literature their entire lives, so without fully understanding the work that goes into programming gameplay and graphics engines, video games seem fairly dull for the most part.

We got hooked with addictive gameplay and were happy when story and presentation were added. We waited until games became more advanced to try and tell our parents that it's a respectable medium, but because they haven't followed the medium for decades the way we have, the advances aren't nearly as impressive compared to the art forms they prefer.

Or they're technophobes and aren't ready for anything more demanding than finger-typing on a word processor, in the case of my mom.

Ben said...

I do think it's a problem with the medium that the majority of games look pretty similar at first glance to the average consumer.

Ian Riley said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Doug Brown said...

Hey, could be worse. If I tried to show my dad how to use the 360, it'd go something like:

Me: So it plays games, sure, but right now I'm streaming music from my computer in the office upstairs. And here's where I can watch Netflix movies. I've got like a hundred lined up right now. Pretty cool, huh?

Dad: Is the Lakers game on?

Ian Riley said...

Clever. I really enjoyed this article, it put an inexplicable smile on my face.

I didn't get a chance to spend the holiday with mi familia, I suppose I miss my folks. O_Q

Justin said...

That was great, Leigh! Very relatable. My mom used to pull that exact same vacuuming stunt. Even now, whenever I visit her, she finds passive-aggressive ways to insinuate herself between me and my games. It never fails that if I'm lying in bed, playing my PSP or DS, she'll come in, sit on the edge of the bed, and start a conversation with me, as if I'm doing absolutely nothing.

Salsaman1991 said...

My dad was who introduced me to videogames, and to this day he still enjoys racing games. Particularly Mario Kart. Sometimes he sits down on the couch and takes an interest on whatever I'm playing. He likes understanding the gameplay mechanics and visual cues, even when he's not playing himself.

He likes to criticize, though. A lot. Specially things he finds don't make sense or are too bizarre. The perfect example of this was the final boss battle in Okami.

My mother hates videogames. She doesn't even get Wii Sports.

I agree with your dad about pictures. You should use them more often. But somehow, the subheads just don't fit in well with your articles. Well, whatever, I'm a fiction writer/poet, not a journalist, anyways :P

Michael Abbott said...

I think these occasional reality checks are very useful. We're such an insular community with our own jargon and collective set of experiences. You really only need step a few paces away to realize that a whole lot of smart, well-informed folks have very little interest in what we're so captivated by. Sort of puts the brouhahas and flamewars in perspective.

Nice photo, Leigh. That's what I call a happy couple!

beeporama said...

Nice subheads and pictures. :) Now we know where you get your good looks as well as your contrarian nature!

I tend to think including the Blu-Ray player in the PS3 lost this generation of the console war, but won this generation of the format war. People kept insisting HD-DVD had it because "porn adopted it," but Sony won out thanks to the PS3 install base. I agree the price is killing them, but it might still have been the best business decision for the company as a whole.

It's interesting to hear things from your point of you. I come from a family of non-gamers, and I'm the only person among my close friends who games regularly (or at all in many cases), so these "reality checks" are second nature. At least I was able to get my technophile father to watch part of Gears of War 2...

beeporama said...

@Fred Zeleny: Apparently, no one had ever considered the player might try following the law. Crazy, huh?

A long-time hardcore gamer, the first time I ran over somebody in GTA4, I guiltily called 911. But since *I* was fine, they wanted nothing to do with the poor guy lying on the ground. I can't believe no playtester thought of that.

Samit said...

Great article, Leigh! My parents are quite unlike yours -- well, they're in their fifties, but they're pretty much tech-illiterate. I'm talking "how do you switch from TV to the DVD player" tech-illiterate. Seriously, I have to be around (or available by phone) to troubleshoot everything for them.

They simply don't seem to understand my love of video games ("waste of time" argument, etc.). But that's okay. Different strokes for different folks, I guess.

Julian said...

I always love hearing about peoples' families' take on video games. ^_^

My parents were always surprisingly active with video games when I was a kid. I think they just liked being a part of my hobbies, but both my parents got genuinely hooked on RPGs like Final Fantasy and Dragon Warrior. My dad is a textbook hardcasualist, logging hundreds of hours on games like Civilization. My mom used to be the best Tetris player in the land, but he's lost her edge and mainly plays Zelda and Brain Age nowadays.

I think the deal in Driver is that you're a criminal and all of the missions focus around you driving crazily and avoiding the cops. It's an oversight not to have a cop pop out and arrest you if you're stopped, but obeying the law is outside the scope of the game. It's out of character for your avatar too, since even getting pulled over for a speeding ticket would mean a trip to jail, given your criminal history.

Doug S. said...

My mom is fanatically anti-video game. She says they have no merit whatsoever, and "are bad for your brain." She also believes that the use of the word "boss" for major enemies in video games is a Japanese plot to destroy American industry, by causing children to associate their supervisors at work with enemies to be defeated.

On the other hand, she loves Tetris and similar games - to the point where she refuses to play them, because if she gets started, that's all she'll do.

My father doesn't understand why anyone would want to "work" for his or her entertainment, preferring to passively watch television. "But it's just little men running around on a screen! Why do you care?"

Pete said...

Wow, do you people ever make me feel old (I'm 48). I wonder where all your parents were while I was hanging out at the bar playing that new-fangled Pong game and lamenting the death of pinball?

And I bought a PS3 because of the blu-ray player. More correctly, I bought the PS3 as early as I did because of the blu-ray player; I'm sure I would've bought one eventually for the games.

Nab said...

Sorry to chime in on a negative point, but I think your father does have a point... As I get more and more interested in video game journalism, I tend to get turned off by articles that are pretty long to read.

I don't know if it's really the length of the articles, or the depth though... I don't know if I really want to "overanalyse" the games I play :P

On the bright side, you're far from the only one doing this... Look at N'Gai :P

P.S. : I jave both of you on my RSS reader, so take that as constructive criticism :P

David said...

I really enjoyed reading this article, thank you! My own parents aren't interested in games beyond the occasional shot of handheld Tetris, and back in the 90's my dad and I would spend hours at a time playing Dr. Robotnik's Mean Bean Machine. My dad's quite a big snooker fan, so I'll have to take round the PS2 and the snooker game I've got this Christmas, see what he thinks of it...

Glen said...

You're posts are a little long. But I'm in no place to critique. I should be learning from you, seeing as this is what I want to do.

Alvin said...

Hmm... subheads and pictures... works for me.

I was reading the article and kept thinking about my grandfather. He owned an Atari 2600 and an Intellivision and going to his house way back in the 80s was fun for a young child. I wouldn't doubt it if he was the first person ever to own those.

Now he wants a PS3 despite having missed out on the intermediate generations. He claims to be tech-savvy so he wants to have a Blu-ray player. The PS3 is also a reason to have the grand and great-grandkids over to the house again. And he has a 52" Sony Bravia.

I'm just kinda worried that he'll start hanging around on Home and tell people to get off his virtual lawn.

spitfire said...

I suppose I should feel lucky that my Dad and I got to play two rounds of Tiger 08 in Match Play over Thanksgiving then!

Although my Dad and I were playing Missile Command in our pajamas all day on the 2600 back in 81, so this isn't anything recent.

Get your Dad some GT5 Prologue if he's into driving games. It's sooooooo good.

Kenny said...

I get to the bottom...
I do have to admit that the casual readers will not get to the bottom. See Kotaku comments, Leigh. See Kotaku comments.

keith said...

It's not often that an article in my feedreader makes me feel homesick.

Can't say that my parents have remotely the same background but I've seen some similar reactions from them when I've been "justifying the pile of boxes under the TV".

Aside from the sheer fun of playing games with older folks (my parents are the youngest in the extended family, so it runs up to 70s), what I find really nice about sharing some of the fun of gaming with them is seeing the myths evaporate with no prompting.

From a laptop, a spare LCD and a copy of "Who wants to be a Millionaire", to Singstar and Guitar Hero on PS2, to Wii Sports, at our extended-family Christmas and summer parties EVERYONE wants to play. Getting calls from older relatives just to make sure I'm bringing *something* ("Can you bring that golf game? I want to embarrass your Uncle T again"). No-one's too worried about about the gaming-induced downfall of society in my family. It's all too much fun.

And now I can't wait for Christmas. I wonder if "You're in the movies" might amuse?

Roy said...

It's similar for me. My Dad is interested in the technology and hardware, and I can have great conversations with him about interfaces or graphics or connectivity, but I don't think he sees anything worthwhile in gaming itself.

I suspect my Mum is a prime candidate for Imagine: Kitten Stroking, mind.

Hughes. said...

"Well then, what's that?" Dad points at the screen, where my big pistol is filling up the corner of the first-person view. "Why do you have a gun if it's not a shooter? It sure looks like a shooter to me."

See, I've been saying this same thing about Metroid Prime for years, First Person Adventure my tushie!!

Anonymous said...

I totally get what you're saying, Leigh. The passive aggressive tricks, the refusal to see anything interesting or even different in games - that characterises my parents too.

Their ignorance borders on the offensive, as far as I'm concerned. Especially in your case, as you've made a career out of games.

And I always reach the bottom of your articles. Every. Single. One.

SVGL said...

Actually, Anonymous, that wasn't my point about my parents. I'm often writing about how it's important for games to understand how "normal people" -- i.e, nongamers, different demographics than we're used to, etc. -- perceive video games, and I just found it fascinating how like, our whole value system isn't visible to your regular folks coming in from the outside.

Ben said, "I do think it's a problem with the medium that the majority of games look pretty similar at first glance to the average consumer," and that's one of the things I learned here.

And, thank you, and the others who get to the bottom of my articles. :)

Cameron aka Cam said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Cameron aka Cam said...

Another great article. I believe that's why Nintendo is so successful. They try to get "normal" people involved. Personally I really enjoy the Gaming Community and being described as "different" because of my hobbies. My mom's side of the family is pretty strict on gaming but it's because of games my dad, sister, and I have the close relationship we share today. So basically thanks for another great article and while pictures would be great, I really enjoy the articles just as they are. Besides, I get to the bottom of every article and I have a short attention span.
SVGL + 10 xp! You've kept my attention longer than 5 minutes.

Julian said...

About the length, they are long, but to me that's a good thing. It just means you have more time to go in-depth. I DO like the subheads and pics though. It's like the jalapenos on nachos. It's not necessary for it to be delicious, but it add that special spice that really takes it to the next level.

Andrew said...

Just wanted to say I've been visiting your blog for a long time now, and I do love hearing your opinions on things, but this is the first article I've read all the way through in quite a long time.

Your Dad knows his stuff!

You should definitely keep this style up.

Mike D said...

I think part of the reason why I got into writing is because of my family. My mother wasn't much of a book reader, but when I was a kid she gave me a subscription to this readers book club. Then as I got older, I remember my older brother playing videogames and reading a lot, and since I thought everything he did was cool, I copied him. Reading, writing, gaming; my trinity.

How did my dad contribute? Well, I remember this one time when he beat me with a rolled up newspaper.

Pepe said...

You know...

I really like your large rants.

I know it's not the "right thing" but... I just like them and hope you continue this way. They are quite entertaining ^_^.

Oliver Snyders said...

EL OH EL!

Your dad's comments and advice were classic! Saying it straight, like only a dad can ;)

I Am Dali said...

About the Fallout 3 / Just A Guy With A Gun In A Wasteland reduction thing:

I think we can learn a whole huge load of things about games from the reactions of non-gamers. (I first noticed it when I beta-tested a computer game at a development studio, and went with two non-gamer friends)

Where a gamer sees something amazing, immersive, and exciting a non-gamer sees something contrived, flat, gimmicky, or boring. Where a gamer either likes or doesn't really consciously notice a control scheme or graphical interface, a non-gamer is repelled by the complexity.

My new belief is that non-gamers have higher standards than gamers, and/or that our imaginations work in fundamentally different ways.

Darkness U.S.A said...

I get to the bottom of your articles, most of the time by scrolling down to the end, lol.sorry if this gets me banned from the site and I mean no offense but I have to agree with your pop. I don't expect you to simply write "I like game X "and that is it but it seems at times we are treated to a Bob Costas, Cliff Clavin type article way too often just to see how long a post can be,I hope you are paid by the word as a journalist because you would clean up. But I do enjoy coming to the site

shoinan said...

:) Bless.

Fred's Gunn said...

Dude, I also get to the bottom of your articles. I wish I could ever get my parents to look at a video game. The closest I came was when my dad checked out Madden 09, only because he loves football.

Jackarooty said...

"the only involvement Mom had with video game consoles was to passive-aggressively vacuum over the controller cords while I was trying to play."

I did get to the bottom of the article but I can't stop laughing about Mom.

TSPhoenix said...

The only games my Dad will touch are racing games. I find typically even the most ardent game hating fathers will mellow down to a racer.

I've tried to show him a select few other games over the years, or he has just watched me play them. The biggest response I've got was "I can see how someone could get into this" in response to of all things MGS2, he only say cutscenes and the Rose+Jack conversations which to be honest if I'd never heard of Metal Gear Solid would not have sold me on the game.

Another moment I remember is thinking I had the house to myself and playing RE4 to get walked in on as I mowed down what to the untrained eye look like priestly figures, just got a few dirty looks.

That said I just got a PS3 so I'm looking forward to trying to show my Dad Dead Space and of course GT5, I think they have a fairly universal Dad-appeal factor.

As for my mother, sadly she is near incapable of recreation, so the idea of any type of game is beyond her it seems.

Anonymous said...

So... if you're holding a sword it's a Role Playing Game. But if you're holding a gun it's not?

Dom said...

Have to say I see it more of an FPS than an RPG.

It has RPG elements, but it's nothing like Final Fantasy. Feels more like Bioshock. In a nuclear wasteland. With stats. Mixed with Oblivion.